Contango, backwardation and roll yield
Why futures for different months trade at different prices, what contango and backwardation mean, how rolling creates a hidden gain or loss called roll yield, and why futures-based funds can drift far from the spot price.
The futures curve
For most commodities, futures are listed for many delivery months at once. If you plot each month's price, you get the futures curve (or forward curve). Its shape tells you what the market is paying today for the same commodity at different future dates.
Two shapes have names, and they matter a lot for anyone who holds futures-based products.
Contango: later is more expensive
The CFTC glossary defines contango as a market in which prices in succeeding delivery months are progressively higher than in the nearest delivery month.
Example curve (illustrative numbers):
| Delivery | Price |
|---|---|
| Next month | 70.00 |
| In 2 months | 70.80 |
| In 3 months | 71.50 |
| In 6 months | 73.00 |
Why would the market do this? A big reason is the cost of carry. If you buy oil today and store it for six months, you pay for storage, insurance and the interest you could have earned on your money. A futures price further out tends to reflect those costs. Contango is common when supply is plentiful and inventories are high.
Backwardation: later is cheaper
The CFTC glossary defines backwardation as a market in which futures prices are progressively lower in the distant delivery months.
Example curve (illustrative numbers):
| Delivery | Price |
|---|---|
| Next month | 70.00 |
| In 2 months | 69.40 |
| In 3 months | 68.90 |
| In 6 months | 67.50 |
Backwardation often appears when the commodity is scarce right now. Users who need it immediately will pay a premium for having it in hand, sometimes called the convenience yield: the benefit of physically holding the stuff, such as keeping a factory running, when supply is tight.
Curves can change shape quickly, and they can be contango at one end and backwardation at the other.
Roll yield: the hidden gain or loss
Here is why this matters to investors. A fund that holds futures must keep rolling, selling the expiring contract and buying a later one (see: Spot vs futures, contract specs and rolling).
- In contango, it sells the cheaper near contract and buys the more expensive later one. As time passes, that later contract tends to drift down toward the spot price as it approaches expiry, if spot stays unchanged. The fund keeps buying high and selling low. FINRA describes this as rolling into a more expensive contract, resulting in a loss, or negative roll yield.
- In backwardation, the fund sells the expensive near contract and buys a cheaper later one, which tends to drift up toward spot. This produces positive roll yield.
Worked example: same spot price, different outcomes (illustrative numbers)
Assume the spot price of a commodity stays at 70 for a whole year, and a fund rolls monthly.
- Steady contango, with each next-month contract about 1% above the expiring one: each month the fund loses roughly 1% to the roll. Over twelve rolls that compounds to a loss of about 11%, even though the spot price has not moved.
- Steady backwardation, with each next-month contract about 1% below: each roll gains roughly 1%, about 13% over the year with a flat spot price.
Real curves are never this steady, and funds also earn interest on the cash they hold as collateral, but the direction of the effect is real. Over long periods it can dominate the result.
Why your fund does not match the headline price
FINRA's notice on oil-linked products in 2020 made the point plainly: these products generally track oil futures, not the spot price, and some retail investors and even professionals mistakenly treated them as proxies for spot. FINRA noted that the oil market was in "super-contango" as storage capacity ran short, which could worsen losses for investors holding the products for long periods. Over longer horizons, it said, these futures-market features can make a futures-linked product's performance diverge from the spot commodity.
justETF's explainer on exchange-traded commodities makes the same point for European products: oil, natural gas and agricultural ETCs track futures rather than spot, the issuer must roll them forward, and roll gains or losses can significantly affect performance.
Where long-run commodity returns come from
If a commodity itself pays no income, where does any long-run return from commodity futures come from? Researchers break the return of a fully collateralised futures position into parts:
- Spot return: the change in the underlying price.
- Roll yield: the gain or loss from rolling along the curve.
- Collateral return: interest earned on the cash backing the position.
Gorton and Rouwenhorst's study of an equally weighted index of commodity futures from 1959 found that fully collateralised commodity futures historically offered returns and risk-adjusted returns similar to equities over their sample, attributing this to a risk premium paid by hedgers for transferring price risk. A follow-up paper ten years later reported that most findings held out of sample. That is a historical, diversified result; it says little about any single commodity or any particular decade, and different studies and periods give different answers.
Practical questions before buying a futures-based product
- Which contracts does it hold, and how often does it roll?
- What shape is the curve for that commodity right now, and how has it typically looked?
- Does it hold near-month contracts (most exposed to roll costs) or spread across later months?
- What are the fees, and how has the product's return compared with the spot price over several years?
Key takeaways
- The futures curve shows prices for different delivery months.
- Contango: later months cost more, often reflecting storage and financing costs.
- Backwardation: later months cost less, often reflecting current scarcity.
- Rolling in contango creates negative roll yield; in backwardation, positive roll yield.
- Futures-based funds can diverge significantly from the spot price, as FINRA warned in 2020.
Common mistakes
Buying an oil or natural-gas fund expecting it to follow the spot price over months or years, ignoring the curve's shape, and comparing a futures fund with the headline price without counting roll and fees.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice.
Test yourself
- The two-month future is priced above the one-month future. Is the market in contango or backwardation? Answer: Contango.
- Why does rolling in contango tend to lose money if the spot price stays flat? Answer: The fund repeatedly sells the cheaper expiring contract and buys a more expensive later one, which tends to drift down toward spot as it nears expiry.
- What are the three components of a collateralised futures return? Answer: Spot price change, roll yield and interest on the collateral.
Sources
- CFTC - Glossary (contango, backwardation)
- FINRA - Regulatory Notice 20-14 (oil-linked exchange-traded products)
- FINRA - Regulatory Notice 10-51 (commodity futures-linked securities)
- justETF - Exchange-traded commodities, what is an ETC?
- Gorton and Rouwenhorst - Facts and Fantasies about Commodity Futures (NBER Working Paper 10595)
- Bhardwaj, Gorton and Rouwenhorst - Facts and Fantasies about Commodity Futures Ten Years Later (NBER Working Paper 21243)
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.