ETFs, ETCs, ETNs and physical holdings compared

The different wrappers that give you commodity exposure, from coins and bars to physically backed funds, futures-based funds, exchange-traded commodities and notes, and what each one really means you own.

The question that matters: what do I actually own?

Two products can both have "gold" or "oil" in their name and behave very differently, because they are built differently. Before comparing fees or past returns, ask what legal claim you hold and on what. The main options are below.

1. Physical holdings

Buying coins or bars means you own the metal directly. It is mainly practical for precious metals (gold, silver, platinum); nobody keeps barrels of crude in the garage.

Advantages: direct ownership, no issuer or fund in between, no roll costs.

Costs and risks:

2. Physically backed exchange-traded products

These trade on a stock exchange like a share and hold actual metal in vaults on behalf of investors. In the United States many are structured as trusts; in Europe they are usually exchange-traded commodities (ETCs).

Advantages: easy to buy and sell through a normal brokerage account, tracks the spot metal price closely (minus fees), professional storage.

Costs and risks: an annual fee, which over time slowly reduces how much metal each unit represents; the product structure itself, discussed below.

3. Futures-based funds

These hold futures contracts instead of the commodity and roll them as they expire. This is how most products give exposure to oil, natural gas, agricultural goods and broad commodity indices.

Advantages: exposure to commodities that cannot practically be stored by a fund.

Costs and risks: roll yield can add or subtract substantially (see: Contango, backwardation and roll yield). FINRA warned in 2020 that these products track futures, not spot, and that investors had mistaken them for spot proxies. FINRA also described how the largest oil-linked product exhausted the shares it was allowed to issue under its registration, after which its market price diverged significantly from the value of its holdings.

4. ETCs in Europe: a debt security, not a fund

In Europe, rules for ordinary investment funds (UCITS) require diversification, which is why, as justETF explains, most European countries have no single-commodity gold or oil ETF. Single-commodity exposure is usually provided by ETCs instead.

5. Exchange-traded notes (ETNs)

An ETN is an unsecured debt note from a bank or issuer that promises to pay the return of an index. There is often no collateral. If the issuer gets into trouble, holders can lose money even if the index did well. Issuers can also close an ETN early: FINRA reported that in April 2020 the issuer of a WTI-linked ETN announced an early liquidation.

6. Leveraged and inverse products

Some products aim for two or three times the daily move of a commodity, or the opposite of it. FINRA notes that leveraged and inverse products are generally designed for a single day (or similarly short period) and are not intended as buy-and-hold investments; over longer periods their returns can differ significantly from the multiple of the index's return, especially in volatile markets.

A comparison table

WrapperYou ownTracksMain extra risks
Coins and barsThe metalSpot, minus spreadsStorage, theft, dealer spreads
Physically backed fund or ETCFund shares or secured notes backed by vaulted metalSpot, minus feesStructure, custodian, fees
Futures-based fundFund shares holding futuresFutures, not spotRoll yield, share-issuance limits
Swap-based ETCSecured notes, collateral not the commodityIndex via swapIssuer and counterparty
ETNUnsecured issuer debtIndexIssuer credit, early closure
Leveraged or inverseFund or note with derivativesDaily multipleCompounding drift over time

Worked example: fees on a physical gold product (illustrative numbers)

You invest 10,000 in a physically backed gold product with a 0.25% annual fee. If gold's price is unchanged for ten years, the fee gradually reduces the metal behind your units, and your holding is worth about 9,753. The fee is small, but it is certain, while any gain is not. Compare that with buying a small coin at a 5% premium over spot and selling at 2% below spot: you need gold to rise about 7% just to break even on the trade (illustrative numbers).

Questions to ask before buying any commodity product

The World Gold Council, a gold industry body, reminds readers in its own material that diversification does not guarantee returns and past performance is not a guide to the future, which applies to every product here.

Key takeaways

Common mistakes

Assuming every "gold" or "oil" product tracks the spot price, ignoring issuer risk in notes, buying leveraged products to hold for months, and paying large premiums on small coins.

This article is educational and not personal financial advice.

Test yourself

  1. Why are single-commodity products in Europe usually ETCs rather than ETFs? Answer: EU fund rules (UCITS) require diversification, so single-commodity exposure is usually offered as an exchange-traded debt security (ETC).
  2. What is the key extra risk of an ETN compared with a physically backed fund? Answer: It is usually unsecured debt, so you depend on the issuer's ability to pay; it can also be closed early.
  3. Why might a leveraged commodity product not deliver twice the commodity's return over a year? Answer: It targets a multiple of daily returns, and compounding over many volatile days makes longer-term results drift from that multiple.

Sources

For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.