Oil, supply shocks, weather and geopolitics

What moves the price of oil, from OPEC decisions and global demand to inventories and financial markets, plus how supply shocks, weather and geopolitics move energy and farm commodities, with real historical examples.

Why oil matters so much

Oil fuels most of the world's transport and is a raw material for plastics, chemicals and fertilisers. Its price feeds into the cost of nearly everything that has to be moved or made. That is why oil price swings show up in inflation figures, company profits, currency moves and even elections.

There is no single "oil price". The two most quoted benchmarks are WTI (West Texas Intermediate, the US benchmark, whose main futures contract delivers at Cushing, Oklahoma) and Brent (from the North Sea, used as a reference for much of the world's oil). Different grades and locations trade at differences to these benchmarks.

What drives the oil price: the EIA's framework

The US Energy Information Administration groups the main drivers into seven factors:

  1. Supply from OPEC countries. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and its partners can raise or cut output targets, which markets watch closely.
  2. Supply from non-OPEC countries, including the US, whose output responds to prices and technology over time.
  3. Demand in OECD countries, the mostly wealthier economies.
  4. Demand in non-OECD countries, the rest of the world, including large and fast-changing emerging economies.
  5. The supply-demand balance and inventories. Stocks of oil in storage act as a buffer; falling inventories signal a tight market, rising ones a loose market.
  6. Spot prices for physical crude.
  7. Financial markets: trading and investment flows in futures and related markets, as distinct from the physical market.

The key word, as in every market, is expectations. Oil prices react to what traders think supply and demand will be in coming months, so an announcement of future production cuts can move prices before any barrel changes hands.

Why oil prices swing so hard

In the short run, both supply and demand for oil are inelastic: they barely change when prices change. People still need to drive to work; wells and refineries cannot be built overnight. So when supply or demand shifts even a little, the price has to move a lot to bring them back into balance. Small imbalances, big price moves.

Case 1: the 1973-74 oil shock

The Federal Reserve History essay on the oil shock describes how the Organization of Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries began an embargo against the United States in October 1973, during the Yom Kippur War. Oil prices nearly quadrupled, from 2.90 dollars a barrel before the embargo to 11.65 dollars in January 1974, and stayed high after the embargo was lifted in March 1974. The essay explains that higher oil prices tend to produce both higher inflation and slower growth, a painful combination for central banks.

Lesson: geopolitical supply disruptions can produce sudden, large and lasting price changes, with effects far beyond energy markets.

Case 2: April 2020, when oil went negative

The opposite extreme came in 2020. The CFTC's interim staff report describes an oversupplied market at the start of the year, an unprecedented collapse in demand as COVID-19 stopped travel, and concerns about storage. On 20 April 2020 the expiring May WTI futures contract settled at minus 37.63 dollars per barrel (see: Spot vs futures, contract specs and rolling).

Lesson: demand shocks and physical constraints such as storage can push prices to levels that seemed impossible.

Case 3: oil, the dollar and inflation, 2021-22

A BIS study (March 2023) found that commodity prices and the US dollar had usually moved in opposite directions until 2021, so their effects tended to offset each other for importing countries. From 2021 they rose together, compounding the risk of high inflation with weak growth. One enduring reason the authors give is that the US had shifted from energy importer to exporter, making the dollar behave more like "a commodity currency" (see: The dollar, inflation and hedge claims examined).

Weather: the big driver for farm and gas markets

Weather matters for many commodities:

Markets react to forecasts, not just actual weather. A forecast of drought can move grain prices months before harvest, and a better-than-feared harvest can send them down.

Other supply shocks

Worked example: inelastic demand (illustrative numbers)

Suppose the world uses 100 units of oil a day, and a disruption removes 2 units. Consumers cannot quickly use 2% less, and other producers cannot quickly pump 2% more. If, in the short run, a 10% price increase only reduces demand by 0.5%, the price may need to rise by something like 30% or more before enough demand is cut and enough extra supply appears. A 2% supply shock can mean a price shock many times larger. Real markets are messier, with inventories and spare capacity softening the blow, but the principle is why oil can jump so fast.

Key takeaways

Common mistakes

Assuming a geopolitical headline will move prices in an obvious direction (markets may already expect it), forgetting that forecasts move prices before events happen, and trading energy products without understanding that they track futures, not spot.

This article is educational and not personal financial advice. Energy and agricultural prices can be extremely volatile.

Test yourself

  1. Why can a small supply disruption cause a large oil price rise? Answer: Short-run supply and demand are inelastic, so the price must move a lot to rebalance them.
  2. Name three of the EIA's seven factors that drive crude oil prices. Answer: Any three of: OPEC supply, non-OPEC supply, OECD demand, non-OECD demand, supply-demand balance and inventories, spot prices, financial markets.
  3. What did the 1973-74 embargo do to oil prices, according to Federal Reserve History? Answer: Prices nearly quadrupled, from 2.90 to 11.65 dollars a barrel by January 1974.

Sources

For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.