Spot vs futures, contract specs and rolling

How a futures contract works, what is written in its contract specifications, why margin creates leverage, how contracts expire and get settled, and why anyone holding futures long-term has to keep rolling them.

Spot: the price for now

The spot price is the price for buying a commodity for immediate delivery. If a refinery buys a cargo of crude to be delivered in the next few days, it pays roughly the spot price, adjusted for quality and location. The CFTC glossary defines basis as the difference between the spot (cash) price and the price of the nearest futures contract, which can reflect differences in time, location, grade and form.

Most people never deal in spot commodities directly. They see futures prices.

Futures: a promise about the future

A futures contract is a standardised agreement, traded on an exchange, to buy or sell a set quantity of a commodity at a set price on a set future date. The CFTC glossary highlights four features: the price is fixed when the contract is made, both sides are obliged to fulfil it, it is used to shift price risk, and it is satisfied either by delivery or by offset (taking an opposite position before expiry).

Worked example (illustrative numbers). A wheat farmer expects to harvest in four months. Today's futures price for that month is 6.00 per bushel. The farmer sells futures at 6.00. If at harvest the price has fallen to 5.00, the farmer sells the wheat for 5.00 in the local market but gains about 1.00 on the futures, roughly locking in 6.00. If the price rises to 7.00, the farmer loses about 1.00 on the futures but sells the crop for more. Either way, the outcome is close to 6.00. That certainty is the point of hedging.

Contract specifications: the small print

Every futures contract has a contract specification set by the exchange. Typical items:

A real example: CME Group's NYMEX Light Sweet Crude Oil futures (ticker CL), the main US oil contract, cover 1,000 barrels per contract, have a minimum price move of one cent per barrel (10 dollars per contract), and are physically settled with delivery at Cushing, Oklahoma, a major US pipeline and storage hub.

That last detail matters. Someone holding that contract at expiry is obliged to take, or make, delivery of 1,000 barrels of oil at Cushing. Ordinary investors do not want that.

Physical delivery versus cash settlement

Margin and leverage

You do not pay the full value of a futures contract up front. You post initial margin, which the CFTC describes as funds put up as security to guarantee fulfilment of the contract. Margin is typically a small fraction of the contract's value, which creates leverage: small price changes produce large gains or losses relative to the money you put in.

Positions are marked to market daily: gains are credited and losses debited from your account each day. If losses push your account below the required level, you get a margin call and must add money or have the position closed.

Worked example (illustrative numbers). One contract controls 1,000 barrels at 80, a value of 80,000. Suppose required margin is 8,000. If oil falls 5 to 75, you lose 5,000, which is 62.5% of your margin, on a 6.25% price move. The CFTC warns, in the context of leveraged trading generally, that customers can lose more than their initial investment.

Rolling: staying invested in something that expires

Because each contract expires, anyone who wants continuous exposure has to roll: sell the contract that is about to expire and buy a later one. Commodity funds and exchange-traded products that hold futures do this on a schedule. FINRA describes oil-linked products replacing shorter-dated contracts with longer-dated ones, often over several days.

Rolling looks like an administrative detail, but it can have a big effect on returns. When the later contract is more expensive than the expiring one, the roll costs money; when it is cheaper, the roll adds money. This is the subject of the next article (see: Contango, backwardation and roll yield).

When expiry goes wrong: April 2020

The danger of being caught near expiry was shown on 20 April 2020. According to the CFTC staff report, the May 2020 WTI contract fell from 17.73 dollars per barrel to settle at minus 37.63 dollars, the day before it expired, the first negative price since the contract was listed 37 years earlier. The CFTC staff pointed to an oversupplied market, a collapse in demand during COVID-19, and concerns about the availability of storage, and noted that liquidity in the expiring contract had been falling. With nowhere to put the oil, some holders effectively paid others to take their contracts.

Ordinary investors in oil-linked funds were also affected. FINRA reported that the largest oil-related exchange-traded product lost 41% of its value in one week to 22 April 2020 and then shifted into longer-dated contracts.

Key takeaways

Common mistakes

Treating a futures price as the price you can buy and hold, ignoring the last trading day and first notice day, trading futures without understanding margin calls, and assuming a futures-based fund will match the spot price.

This article is educational and not personal financial advice. Futures are leveraged and can produce losses larger than your initial deposit.

Test yourself

  1. A futures contract controls 50,000 worth of a commodity and requires 5,000 margin. The price falls 4%. What happens to your margin, roughly? Answer: You lose about 2,000, which is 40% of your 5,000 margin.
  2. What does it mean to roll a futures position? Answer: Closing the contract near expiry and opening a later-dated one to keep the exposure.
  3. Why did the May 2020 WTI contract settle below zero? Answer: According to the CFTC staff, oversupply, collapsing demand and storage concerns, with falling liquidity, left holders near expiry unable to find buyers who could take delivery.

Sources

For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.