The dollar, inflation and hedge claims examined
Why commodities and the US dollar are linked, what the research actually says about commodities and gold as inflation hedges, and how to read bold "hedge" claims with a critical eye.
Commodities speak dollars
Most internationally traded commodities, including oil, gold, copper and many farm products, are priced and invoiced in US dollars. The BIS study by Hofmann, Park and Pierres Tejada (March 2023) spells out what that implies: a stronger dollar raises the local-currency price of commodities for everyone outside the US, and it also tightens global financial conditions through investors' risk appetite and the supply of dollar credit.
Worked example (illustrative numbers). Oil is 80 dollars a barrel. For a buyer whose currency trades at 1 dollar per unit, a barrel costs 80 units. If the dollar strengthens so that 1 dollar costs 1.25 units, the same 80-dollar barrel now costs 100 units, a 25% increase for that buyer with no change in the dollar price. Higher local prices can reduce demand, which can in turn weigh on the dollar price.
The usual pattern, and when it broke
The BIS authors found that until 2021, commodity prices and the dollar generally moved in opposite directions. A weaker dollar made commodities cheaper for non-US buyers, supporting demand and dollar prices, and vice versa. For commodity-importing countries, the two effects tended to offset each other.
From 2021, however, commodity prices and the dollar rose together, compounding the pain for importers and raising the risk of "stagflation" (high inflation with weak growth). The authors pointed to one lasting reason, the US becoming an energy exporter (making the dollar behave more like a commodity currency), and temporary ones, such as flight-to-safety flows and faster US monetary tightening. Both trends reversed in late 2022.
Lesson: "the dollar and commodities move in opposite directions" is a tendency, not a law. Relationships between markets change.
The inflation-hedge idea
An inflation hedge is an asset expected to hold or gain value when inflation rises, protecting your purchasing power. Commodities are often promoted this way, for an intuitive reason: commodity prices are part of what inflation measures. When oil, food and metals get more expensive, measured inflation rises.
What does the evidence say?
Broad commodity futures
Gorton and Rouwenhorst's study of an equally weighted index of commodity futures from 1959 found that commodity futures returns were positively correlated with inflation, including unexpected inflation and changes in expected inflation, while stock and bond returns were negatively correlated with inflation over the same period. This is the strongest academic support for commodities as an inflation-sensitive asset.
Important qualifications:
- The finding is about a diversified, collateralised index of futures, not a single commodity and not a single fund.
- Correlation is modest and varies over time. Commodities can fall during inflationary periods, and rise when inflation is low.
- Real products suffer roll yield and fees, which can erase the theoretical benefit (see: Contango, backwardation and roll yield). FINRA's 2020 warnings about oil-linked products are a reminder of how far a product can drift from the commodity.
Gold
Gold's reputation as an inflation hedge is strong in popular writing. Erb and Harvey's "The Golden Dilemma" tested it and concluded that gold may be a good inflation hedge over very long periods (they mention centuries) but an unreliable one over horizons up to 20 years, which they argue is the relevant range for most investors. They also found gold to be an unreliable currency hedge.
In plain words: over a lifetime of many generations, gold has broadly kept purchasing power. Over the five, ten or twenty years in which you might actually need your money, its inflation-adjusted value has swung widely.
Why energy shocks are a mixed blessing
When inflation is caused by an energy shock, energy prices rise by definition. But the Federal Reserve History essay on the 1973-74 oil shock notes that higher oil prices tend to bring both higher inflation and slower growth. And the Federal Reserve explains that it typically responds to rising inflation by raising interest rates, which can weigh on many asset prices. So the asset that "caused" the inflation may rise, while the rest of a portfolio suffers. Timing is everything, and nobody reliably times it.
How to read hedge claims critically
When someone says "X is a hedge against Y", ask:
- Over what horizon? A hedge over a century is not a hedge over a year.
- Which version of X? Spot gold, a gold fund, a mining share and a futures index are different things.
- Against which kind of Y? Inflation from an oil shock, from wage growth, and from currency debasement may affect assets differently.
- What is the evidence? Is it a long, independent study, or a chart of a convenient period?
- What does it cost? Storage, fees and roll yield are certain; the hedge benefit is not.
- Who is making the claim? Industry bodies and product sellers have an interest in the conclusion. That does not make them wrong; it does mean you should read independent research too.
A balanced view
Commodities, and gold in particular, have historically behaved differently from shares and bonds, which is a legitimate reason some investors hold a small allocation. The research supports "inflation-sensitive, especially for diversified commodity futures" more than "reliable inflation hedge". Treat strong, simple claims in either direction with caution.
Key takeaways
- Commodities are mostly priced in dollars; a stronger dollar raises their cost for non-US buyers.
- Commodity prices and the dollar usually moved oppositely until 2021, then rose together, per the BIS: relationships change.
- Diversified commodity futures have been positively correlated with inflation historically (Gorton and Rouwenhorst).
- Gold appears to hedge inflation over very long periods but unreliably over horizons up to 20 years (Erb and Harvey).
- Judge hedge claims by horizon, product, type of inflation, evidence, costs and source.
Common mistakes
Buying a single commodity fund as "inflation insurance", relying on one chart of a favourable period, and ignoring costs that erode any hedge benefit.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice.
Test yourself
- The dollar strengthens by 10% against your currency while oil's dollar price is unchanged. What happens to your local cost of oil? Answer: It rises by about 10%.
- What did Gorton and Rouwenhorst find about commodity futures and inflation? Answer: Their returns were positively correlated with inflation (including unexpected inflation), unlike stocks and bonds in their sample.
- Why is "gold is an inflation hedge" an incomplete statement, according to Erb and Harvey? Answer: It may hold over centuries, but over horizons up to 20 years gold has been an unreliable inflation hedge.
Sources
- BIS Quarterly Review (March 2023) - Commodity prices, the dollar and stagflation risk
- Gorton and Rouwenhorst - Facts and Fantasies about Commodity Futures (NBER Working Paper 10595)
- Erb and Harvey - The Golden Dilemma (NBER Working Paper 18706; Financial Analysts Journal 2013)
- Federal Reserve - Monetary Policy, What Are Its Goals? How Does It Work?
- Federal Reserve History - Oil Shock of 1973-74
- FINRA - Regulatory Notice 20-14 (oil-linked exchange-traded products)
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.