What commodities are and how their markets work
The three big families of commodities (energy, metals and agriculture), what makes them different from shares and bonds, who trades them and why, and the main ways an ordinary investor can get exposure.
Raw materials with a price
A commodity is a basic good that is largely interchangeable no matter who produced it. A barrel of a given grade of crude oil, a tonne of copper or a bushel of wheat of a given standard is much like any other. That interchangeability is what allows commodities to be traded on exchanges in standard contracts.
Commodities are usually grouped into three families:
| Family | Examples | What drives demand |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | Crude oil, natural gas, petrol (gasoline), heating oil, coal | Transport, industry, heating, power generation |
| Metals | Precious: gold, silver, platinum. Industrial (base): copper, aluminium, nickel, zinc | Jewellery and investment (precious); construction, electronics, manufacturing (industrial) |
| Agriculture | Grains (wheat, corn, soybeans), softs (coffee, cocoa, sugar, cotton), livestock | Food, animal feed, biofuels, clothing |
How commodities differ from shares and bonds
A share is a claim on a company's future profits; a bond is a claim on future interest payments. A commodity is just stuff. It pays no dividend and no interest. Its price depends on how much is produced, how much is used, how much is stored, and what people expect to happen to those quantities.
This has big consequences:
- No built-in return. A share can grow as the company grows; a barrel of oil does not grow. Any long-run return from holding commodities has to come from somewhere other than the commodity itself, a point covered later (see: Contango, backwardation and roll yield).
- Costs of holding. Physical commodities must be stored, insured and sometimes transported. Oil needs tanks, grain needs silos and can spoil, gold needs a vault.
- Supply responds slowly. Opening a mine or drilling new wells can take years; growing a crop takes a season. When demand jumps, prices can spike because supply cannot quickly follow.
- Weather, politics and accidents matter. A drought, a war, a strike or a pipeline outage can change supply abruptly (see: Oil, supply shocks, weather and geopolitics).
Spot and futures, in one paragraph
The spot price is the price for delivery now (or within a few days). Much of the commodity world, however, trades through futures contracts. The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which regulates US futures markets, defines a futures contract as an agreement to buy or sell a commodity for delivery in the future at a price set when the contract is made, used to shift price risk and settled either by delivery or by offsetting the position. You will meet these in detail in the next article (see: Spot vs futures, contract specs and rolling).
Who trades commodities, and why
- Producers such as farmers, miners and oil companies sell futures to lock in prices for what they will produce, protecting their income from a price collapse. This is hedging.
- Consumers such as airlines, food companies and utilities buy futures to lock in costs and protect against price spikes. Also hedging.
- Traders and merchants move physical goods around the world and trade price differences between places and dates.
- Speculators, from individual traders to funds, take positions hoping to profit from price changes. They provide liquidity, taking the other side of hedgers' trades.
- Investors add commodities to portfolios for diversification, usually through funds that hold futures or, for precious metals, physical metal.
- Central banks are large holders of gold as part of their reserves.
Why investors are interested
There are a few classic arguments for commodities in a portfolio:
- Diversification. Commodity prices often respond to different forces than shares and bonds. Academic research by Gorton and Rouwenhorst, using data from 1959 onward, found that commodity futures returns were negatively correlated with stock and bond returns over their sample, partly because they behave differently over the business cycle.
- Inflation sensitivity. The same research found commodity futures positively correlated with inflation. Whether commodities are a reliable "inflation hedge" for an individual investor's horizon is more contested (see: The dollar, inflation and hedge claims examined).
- Safe-haven demand, especially for gold. The World Gold Council, an industry body, argues gold is a liquid asset with no credit risk that has benefited investors in periods of uncertainty (see: Gold and silver as stores of value).
There are equally real arguments for caution: high volatility, no income, holding and roll costs, and products that do not track the price you see in the news.
Ways to get exposure
| Route | What you own | Main issues |
|---|---|---|
| Physical (coins, bars) | The metal itself | Storage, insurance, dealer spreads; practical mainly for precious metals |
| Futures contracts | Exchange contracts | Leverage, margin calls, expiry and rolling; usually for experienced traders |
| Funds and exchange-traded products | Shares in a fund or a note holding futures or metal | Fees, roll costs, tracking differences, structure risks |
| Producer shares | Shares of miners, oil companies, farmers | Company risks on top of commodity risks |
Each route is covered later in this section (see: ETFs, ETCs, ETNs and physical holdings compared; Producer stocks vs the commodity, and the real costs and risks).
Watching real prices
Commodity prices make the ideas in this section concrete. CryptoAlly (cryptoally.io) shows real prices of 2,344 assets across 42 markets, including futures-based prices for four precious metals (gold, silver, platinum and palladium), which makes it easy to compare, for example, how gold and silver behave on the same day.
Key takeaways
- Commodities are interchangeable raw materials: energy, metals and agriculture.
- Unlike shares and bonds, they pay no income; their price reflects production, consumption, storage and expectations.
- Supply responds slowly, so shocks can cause large price moves.
- Producers and consumers hedge with futures; speculators and investors take the other side.
- Exposure can come from physical holdings, futures, funds or producer shares, each with its own costs and risks.
What to remember
The commodity price in a headline is usually a futures or spot price that most investors cannot simply buy and hold. The product you actually own may behave quite differently.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice. Commodity investments can be highly volatile.
Test yourself
- Why does holding a barrel of oil not produce a return the way owning a share might? Answer: Oil pays no dividend or interest and does not grow; its value depends only on future supply and demand, and holding it costs money.
- What is hedging, in the commodity context? Answer: Using futures to lock in a price in order to reduce risk, as a farmer selling futures or an airline buying fuel futures does.
- Name the three main commodity families. Answer: Energy, metals (precious and industrial) and agriculture.
Sources
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.