Custody, seed phrases and crypto exchanges
The trade-offs between letting an exchange hold your crypto and holding it yourself, how seed phrases work and how to protect them, and what to check before trusting a crypto platform.
Who holds the keys?
In the previous article you saw that owning crypto really means controlling a private key (see: How crypto transactions and wallets work). Custody is the question of who holds that key.
- Custodial: a company, usually an exchange or broker, holds the keys. Your account shows a balance, but legally and technically you have a claim on the company, not direct control of coins on the blockchain.
- Self-custody (also called non-custodial): you hold the keys yourself, in a software wallet or a hardware device.
Crypto users often repeat the phrase "not your keys, not your coins". It captures a real risk, but self-custody has serious risks of its own. Neither option is automatically safe.
Custodial: convenient, with counterparty risk
Advantages:
- Easy to start: sign up, verify your identity, buy.
- Forgotten password? The company can usually help you recover access.
- Simple to convert between crypto and ordinary money.
Risks:
- The company can fail or misuse funds. The collapse of the FTX exchange in late 2022 is the clearest example. In its December 2022 complaint, the SEC alleged that FTX's founder concealed the diversion of customer money to his affiliated trading firm, Alameda Research. Customers who believed their crypto was sitting safely in their accounts found they could not withdraw.
- Hacks. Large platforms are attractive targets. The CFTC warns that hacking and phishing can lead to theft with no assured recourse.
- Weak oversight in some places. The CFTC notes that many crypto cash-market platforms are not overseen by a government agency and may lack customer protections. Some platforms also trade against their own customers, a conflict of interest.
- Frozen access. A platform can freeze or limit withdrawals during stress, legal disputes or compliance checks.
Self-custody: control, with full responsibility
Advantages:
- No company can freeze, lend out or lose your coins.
- You can use decentralised applications directly.
Risks:
- You are the only safety net. Lose your keys and backup, and the funds are gone. No one can reset it.
- You are the target. Phishing sites, fake wallet apps, malicious contract approvals and "support agents" asking for your seed phrase all aim at self-custody users.
- Inheritance. If no one else knows how to access your wallet, your family may never recover it.
Seed phrases explained
Most modern wallets create your keys from a seed phrase (also called a recovery phrase or mnemonic): a list of ordinary words, usually 12 or 24. The common standard, BIP 39, maps random numbers to words from a fixed list of 2,048 words. From that phrase the wallet can regenerate all of your private keys on any compatible device.
That makes the seed phrase the master key to everything in that wallet. Anyone who sees it can take everything. Some wallets also support an optional extra passphrase; under BIP 39, adding a passphrase produces a completely different wallet from the same words, which adds protection but also adds something else you must not forget.
Protecting a seed phrase
- Write it down on paper or stamp it in metal. Store it somewhere safe from fire, water and prying eyes.
- Never type it into a website, email, chat, cloud note or photo. Legitimate support staff never need it.
- Consider keeping more than one copy in separate secure places, accepting that each copy is another place it could be found.
- Test recovery with a small amount before trusting a wallet with significant funds.
- Think about how a trusted person could access it if something happened to you, without exposing it today.
Hot and cold
- A hot wallet is connected to the internet (phone or browser apps). Convenient for small, frequent use, more exposed to malware and phishing.
- A cold wallet keeps keys offline, typically on a hardware device that signs transactions internally. More protection for larger, long-term holdings, at some cost in convenience.
A common pattern is to keep small "spending" amounts hot and larger savings cold, but the right setup depends on your amounts and your comfort with the technology.
Choosing an exchange: what to check
A crypto exchange (or broker) lets you swap ordinary money for crypto and back. Before trusting one, consider:
- Licensing in your jurisdiction. Rules vary widely. In the European Union, the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) requires crypto-asset service providers to be authorised. ESMA, the EU securities regulator, stated that the transitional periods allowing some providers to operate under national regimes ended on 1 July 2026, after which providers without a MiCA licence serving EU clients would be in breach of EU law. Other countries have their own regimes; check your national regulator's register.
- How customer assets are held. Are they segregated from the company's own money? Does the platform lend them out?
- Proof of reserves and audits. Some exchanges publish evidence of what they hold. Useful, but a snapshot of assets says little about hidden liabilities.
- Fees and spreads. "Zero fee" platforms often earn through wider spreads (see: Fees and gas, what you pay to use a blockchain).
- Withdrawal history. Can users withdraw promptly to their own wallets?
- Security features. Two-factor authentication with an app or security key, withdrawal address allow-lists, login alerts.
Worked example: matching custody to amounts (illustrative)
Someone buys a small amount to learn how crypto works. Keeping it on a reputable, licensed exchange with strong two-factor security may be reasonable while they learn. If their holdings grow to an amount they could not afford to lose to a platform failure, many people move most of it to a hardware wallet they control, after practising with small transfers and securing the seed phrase properly. Others prefer regulated investment products that hold crypto through professional custodians. Each route swaps one set of risks for another.
Key takeaways
- Custody is about who holds the private keys: a company (custodial) or you (self-custody).
- Custodial platforms bring counterparty, hack and freezing risk; FTX showed customer funds can be misused.
- Self-custody removes company risk but makes you solely responsible for security and backups.
- A seed phrase regenerates all your keys; anyone who sees it controls your funds.
- Check licensing, asset segregation, fees, withdrawals and security before using any exchange.
Common mistakes
Storing a seed phrase in a photo or cloud note, giving it to fake "support", keeping large amounts on an unregulated platform, and moving everything to self-custody without first practising recovery.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice. Crypto assets are highly volatile and you can lose your entire investment.
Test yourself
- What does "not your keys, not your coins" mean, and what is its limitation? Answer: If a company holds the keys, you rely on that company; but holding keys yourself shifts all security responsibility to you.
- Why is a seed phrase so sensitive? Answer: It can regenerate every private key in the wallet, so whoever has it controls all the funds.
- Name two things to check before using a crypto exchange. Answer: Any two of: licensing in your jurisdiction, segregation of customer assets, fees and spreads, withdrawal reliability, security features, published reserves.
Sources
- BIP 39 - Mnemonic code for generating deterministic keys
- SEC - SEC Charges Samuel Bankman-Fried with Defrauding Investors in Crypto Asset Trading Platform FTX (Press Release 2022-219)
- CFTC - Understand the Risks of Virtual Currency Trading
- ESMA - Statement on the end of transitional periods under MiCA (April 2026)
- Ethereum.org - Ethereum Accounts
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.