Behavioural traps that cost investors money
FOMO, loss aversion, overconfidence, overtrading, anchoring and herd behaviour explained with the research behind them, and practical habits that help you avoid them.
Your brain is part of your portfolio
Most investing mistakes are not caused by a lack of information. They are caused by normal human instincts that work well in daily life and badly in markets. Psychologists and economists have studied these patterns for decades, and the encouraging news is that knowing them helps. You will not eliminate them, but you can build habits that limit the damage.
Loss aversion: losses hurt more than gains feel good
In their 1979 paper on prospect theory, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky showed that people do not treat gains and losses symmetrically. In their model, people's response to outcomes is steeper for losses than for gains: losing 100 feels worse than winning 100 feels good. Later researchers called this loss aversion.
How it costs money:
- Holding losers too long. Selling a losing investment makes the loss feel "real", so people hold on, hoping to get back to even, even when their reasons for owning it are gone.
- Selling winners too early. Locking in a gain feels good, so people take small profits and keep their losers.
- Panic at the worst time. A sharp fall can feel unbearable, leading to selling near the bottom.
Habit that helps: decide before you buy why you own something and what would make you sell, and write it down. Then judge each holding on today's facts, not on the price you paid.
FOMO: fear of missing out
FOMO is the anxiety of watching others profit from something you do not own. It is powerful in markets because rising prices are highly visible: social media, friends, headlines. By the time an asset is everywhere in conversation, much of its rise has often already happened, and new buyers may be the ones left holding it when enthusiasm fades.
FOMO is also a favourite tool of fraudsters. The US Federal Trade Commission lists "pressure to act quickly" and promises of big or guaranteed returns among the warning signs of crypto scams, and notes that "only scammers will guarantee profits or big returns."
Habit that helps: add a waiting period. If an opportunity is genuinely good, it will usually still be reasonable in a week. If it only works if you act today, that is a warning sign.
Overconfidence and overtrading
Most people believe they are better-than-average drivers, and many investors believe they can beat the market. Brad Barber and Terrance Odean studied 66,465 US households with accounts at a large discount broker between 1991 and 1996. According to their published abstract, the households that traded most earned an annual return of 11.4%, while the market returned 17.9%. The average household turned over about 75% of its portfolio a year. The authors concluded that overconfidence can explain high trading levels and the resulting poor performance, and that individual investors who hold stocks directly "pay a tremendous performance penalty for active trading".
The costs of trading are partly visible (commissions, spreads, taxes) and partly invisible (buying after rises, selling after falls). Commission-free apps remove one cost but not the others, and they can make trading feel like a game.
Habit that helps: track your actual results against a simple benchmark, such as a broad index fund, honestly and over years. Many people trade less once they see the comparison.
Anchoring
Anchoring means fixating on a reference number. "It used to be 100, so at 60 it's cheap." But the earlier price may have been an overvaluation; the asset is worth what its future justifies, not what it once cost. Anchoring also shows up as "I'll sell when I get back to what I paid", a number the market does not know or care about.
Herd behaviour
Following the crowd feels safe; if everyone is buying, it seems silly not to. In markets, herding can feed bubbles on the way up and crashes on the way down. The crowd is sometimes right, but "everyone is doing it" is not an investment reason.
Recency bias
People tend to assume the recent past will continue. After several good years, risk feels low; after a crash, risk feels enormous. Both feelings are often strongest exactly when they are least useful.
Confirmation bias
Once we own something, we seek out information that supports our decision and dismiss information that challenges it. Online communities built around a single asset can amplify this. Deliberately reading the strongest case against your investment is one of the most useful habits you can build.
Mental accounting and "house money"
People often treat gains as "house money" and take bigger risks with it, as if money made in the market were less real than wages. A euro or dollar is a euro or dollar wherever it came from.
Panic tools that backfire
Tools meant to protect you can be used emotionally. FINRA warns that a stop order triggered by a brief, sharp dip can sell your position even if the price recovers minutes later, and "once the order is executed, you can't undo that trade" (see: Exchanges, trading hours and order types).
A simple anti-trap toolkit
- Write an investment plan: goals, time horizon, target mix, and rules for when you rebalance or sell.
- Automate: regular contributions on a schedule reduce the temptation to time the market.
- Use cooling-off periods before acting on excitement or fear.
- Check less often: watching prices every hour magnifies emotional reactions to normal volatility.
- Keep a decision journal: record why you bought or sold. Review it a year later.
- Size positions so you can sleep: if a single holding keeps you awake, it is probably too large.
Key takeaways
- Loss aversion makes losses feel worse than equal gains feel good, leading people to hold losers and sell winners.
- FOMO pushes people to buy late and is exploited by scammers who create urgency.
- Research on US households found that those who traded most earned notably less than the market.
- Anchoring, herding, recency bias and confirmation bias all distort decisions.
- Written plans, automation, waiting periods and fewer price checks are practical defences.
What to remember
The market does not know what you paid, how you feel, or what your friends own. Decisions based on any of those three are the ones most worth questioning.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice.
Test yourself
- What did Barber and Odean find about the most active traders in their sample? Answer: They earned 11.4% a year versus 17.9% for the market, which the authors linked to overconfidence.
- What is anchoring, in one sentence? Answer: Fixating on a reference number, such as a past price or your purchase price, instead of judging the investment on current facts.
- Why does a waiting period help against FOMO? Answer: It gives the emotional urge time to fade, and genuine opportunities rarely require instant action, while scams often do.
Sources
- Barber and Odean (2000), Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth, Journal of Finance 55(2) - abstract
- Kahneman and Tversky (1979), Prospect Theory, An Analysis of Decision under Risk, Econometrica 47(2)
- FINRA - Stop Orders, Factors to Consider During Volatile Markets
- FTC - What To Know About Cryptocurrency and Scams
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.