Bull and bear markets, corrections and cycles
What the words bull, bear, correction and drawdown really mean, why markets move in cycles, how circuit breakers work, and why nobody can reliably call the turning points.
The vocabulary
Market commentary is full of animal words. Here is what they usually mean.
- Bear market: FINRA describes a bear market as prices that fall and keep falling, and notes that a decline of 20% or more in a broad market index is the commonly used threshold. The term applies to stocks, bonds and commodities alike.
- Bull market: the opposite, a large and sustained rise in prices. There is no single official percentage for a bull market.
- Correction: FINRA uses this for a reversal of at least 10% before the previous trend resumes, usually describing a drop within a broader rise.
- Drawdown: the fall from a previous peak to a later low, expressed as a percentage. It is the most honest way to describe "how bad did it get".
- Rally and sell-off: informal words for short, sharp moves up and down.
These thresholds are conventions, not laws of nature. A 19% fall is not meaningfully different from a 21% fall; the labels just help people talk about it.
Drawdown arithmetic: why losses hurt more than they look
One of the most useful facts in investing is that losses and gains are not symmetrical.
Worked example (illustrative numbers):
| Fall from peak | Gain needed to get back to the peak |
|---|---|
| 10% | about 11% |
| 20% | 25% |
| 33% | about 50% |
| 50% | 100% |
| 80% | 400% |
If 100 falls 50% to 50, a 50% rise only takes you to 75. You need to double to get back to 100. This is why deep bear markets can take years to recover from, and why highly volatile assets such as many crypto tokens can lose most of their value and never come back.
Why markets move in cycles
Markets do not move in straight lines because the economy and people's moods do not. A simplified cycle looks like this:
- Recovery: after a downturn, prices are low, expectations are gloomy, and any improvement surprises on the upside.
- Expansion: profits grow, confidence builds, borrowing becomes easier, prices rise.
- Late stage / exuberance: optimism runs ahead of reality, valuations stretch, risk-taking increases.
- Contraction: something disappoints, such as rising rates, a shock, or slowing profits. Prices fall, sometimes faster than they rose.
Several forces drive this rhythm:
- The business cycle. Economies alternate between growth and slowdowns. Company profits follow.
- Interest rates and central banks. The US Federal Reserve explains that it raises rates to cool demand when inflation is rising and lowers them to support spending and jobs. Higher rates tend to weigh on asset prices; lower rates tend to support them (see: Interest rates, inflation, central banks and currencies).
- Shocks. Wars, pandemics, financial crises and commodity disruptions can end an expansion abruptly. The Federal Reserve History essay on the 1973-74 oil shock describes how oil prices nearly quadrupled after the Arab oil embargo, adding to inflation and slowing growth at the same time.
- Psychology. Rising prices attract buyers, which pushes prices higher, until they do not. Falling prices can trigger forced or panicked selling (see: Behavioural traps that cost investors money).
Circuit breakers: the market's emergency brake
Very fast falls can trigger automatic pauses. FINRA describes the US market-wide circuit breakers, which are based on the S&P 500's drop from the previous day's close:
- Level 1: a 7% fall before 3:25 p.m. Eastern Time halts trading for 15 minutes.
- Level 2: a 13% fall before 3:25 p.m. halts trading for another 15 minutes.
- Level 3: a 20% fall at any time halts trading for the rest of the day.
The idea is to give people time to absorb information rather than sell in a blind panic. Individual stocks also have their own pause mechanisms, and futures exchanges have their own limits. Crypto platforms generally have no market-wide equivalent.
Can anyone predict the turning points?
Not reliably. There are always commentators who called the last crash, but many of them also called several crashes that never came. Bull markets often keep going longer than sceptics expect, and bear markets often end while the news is still terrible, because prices move on expectations, not on the present.
FINRA's guidance on risk points out that stocks do not always beat bonds and that holding stocks for longer reduces, but does not eliminate, the chance of losing money. That is the honest summary of what history tells us: over long periods, broad stock markets have tended to rise, with painful and unpredictable bear markets along the way. Past patterns are not a promise about the future.
How investors typically handle cycles
Without telling you what to do, here are approaches investors commonly use and their trade-offs:
- Holding a diversified mix and accepting that some years will be bad. Requires a time horizon long enough to wait out a bear market (see: Risk, return, diversification and time horizon).
- Regular investing on a schedule regardless of price, which removes the need to guess the bottom (see: Building a simple portfolio, rebalancing and dollar-cost averaging, in the Stocks, ETFs and more section).
- Rebalancing back to a target mix, which mechanically trims what has risen and adds to what has fallen.
- Market timing, trying to sell before falls and buy before rises. It sounds attractive; doing it consistently is extremely hard, and getting it wrong twice (out too early, back in too late) can be costly.
Key takeaways
- A bear market is commonly defined as a 20% fall in a broad index; a correction as a 10% reversal.
- Losses need bigger percentage gains to recover: a 50% fall needs a 100% gain.
- Cycles are driven by the economy, interest rates, shocks and investor psychology.
- US market-wide circuit breakers pause trading at 7%, 13% and 20% daily falls in the S&P 500.
- Nobody reliably predicts turning points; plans that do not depend on predictions tend to be more robust.
Common mistakes
Selling everything after a big fall and missing the recovery, assuming a bull market will last forever, and underestimating how long it can take to recover from a deep drawdown.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Test yourself
- An asset falls from 200 to 100. What percentage gain does it need to return to 200? Answer: 100%. It has to double.
- What is the commonly used threshold for a bear market, according to FINRA? Answer: A decline of 20% or more in a broad market index.
- What happens under a US Level 3 market-wide circuit breaker? Answer: If the S&P 500 falls 20% from the prior close, trading halts for the rest of the day.
Sources
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.