Liquidity, spread, volume and who is on the other side

Why some assets are cheap and easy to trade while others are costly and jumpy, what the bid-ask spread really costs you, and who the other participants in a market are, from retail investors to funds and market makers.

Liquidity: how easily you can trade

FINRA describes a market as having liquidity when participants can buy and sell quickly without significantly moving the price. Think of it as the depth of the pool. In a deep pool you can jump in and barely make a ripple. In a puddle, one step splashes everything.

Highly liquid examples include large-company shares on major exchanges, major currencies such as the euro against the US dollar, and big government bonds. Less liquid examples include shares of very small companies, many bonds of small issuers, collectibles, property, and most small crypto tokens.

Liquidity is not a fixed property. FINRA notes that it can decline when buyers and sellers become imbalanced or prices get volatile. Assets that trade easily on a calm day can become hard to sell during a panic, exactly when people most want to sell.

The bid-ask spread: the cost you do not see

At any moment an order book shows two key prices:

The gap between them is the bid-ask spread. If you buy at the ask and immediately sell at the bid, you lose the spread. It is a real cost even when your broker charges zero commission.

Worked example (illustrative numbers):

AssetBidAskSpreadSpread as % of price
Large, busy share100.00100.020.020.02%
Small, quiet share4.004.200.20about 5%

In the second case you start a round trip roughly 5% behind before the price has even moved. Trade that share often and the spread alone can eat a large part of any gain. FINRA makes the same point about ETFs: spreads vary widely, from nearly zero to much wider.

Volume: how much is trading

Volume is how many units (shares, contracts, coins) changed hands over a period, usually a day. High volume generally goes with high liquidity and tight spreads, although the two are not identical: a market can have big volume concentrated in a few minutes and very little the rest of the day.

Two cautions:

Market depth and price impact

Market depth is how much is waiting in the order book at prices near the current one. If you want to buy 10,000 shares and only 1,000 are offered at the ask, your order "walks up the book", buying the next 1,000 at a slightly higher price, then the next, and so on. The difference between the first price you saw and your average fill is called price impact or slippage.

Worked example (illustrative numbers). The book offers 1,000 shares at 10.00, 2,000 at 10.05 and 5,000 at 10.20. A market order for 8,000 shares fills at an average of about 10.14, not 10.00. For individual investors trading modest amounts in large shares this is negligible; in small, thin assets it can be significant.

Who is on the other side of your trade?

Every trade has two sides. Knowing who the other participants are helps you understand why prices behave as they do.

The person or firm on the other side of your trade often knows more than you, trades faster than you, or simply has a different goal. That is not sinister, it is how markets work, but it is a good reason to avoid assuming that a quick trade is free money.

Why this matters for you

Liquidity links to a risk FINRA lists directly: liquidity risk, the chance that you cannot cash out when you need to, or only at a poor price. Before buying anything, it is worth asking: How wide is the spread? How much trades on a normal day? Could I sell this quickly in a bad week?

Key takeaways

Common mistakes

Ignoring the spread on small or obscure assets, placing market orders in thin markets, and trusting impressive-looking volume figures without checking where they come from.

This article is educational and not personal financial advice.

Test yourself

  1. A share has a bid of 9.90 and an ask of 10.10. What is the spread as a percentage of the ask, roughly? Answer: 0.20 divided by 10.10, about 2%.
  2. Why might an asset that is easy to sell on a calm day become hard to sell in a crash? Answer: Buyers and liquidity providers step back in stressed markets, so order books thin out and spreads widen.
  3. What do market makers do? Answer: They continuously quote both buy and sell prices, providing liquidity, and earn the spread in return.

Sources

For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.