What a market is and why prices move
A market is simply a place where buyers and sellers agree on a price. This article explains supply and demand, why expectations matter more than today's news, and why prices can move even when nothing seems to happen.
Start with a farmers' market
Picture a Saturday farmers' market. Farmers bring tomatoes, shoppers bring money, and somewhere between "I want 5 for a kilo" and "I'll pay 3" a price gets agreed. Nobody decrees that price. It comes out of many small negotiations between people who want to buy and people who want to sell.
A financial market is the same idea with different goods. Instead of tomatoes, people trade shares (small slices of ownership in a company), bonds (loans to governments or companies), currencies, commodities such as oil or gold, and newer things such as crypto assets. The meeting place is usually electronic rather than a field, and trades happen in fractions of a second, but the core mechanism has not changed: a trade happens only when a buyer and a seller agree on a price.
That single fact explains a lot. Every time you see a price on a screen, it is the price at which the most recent buyer and seller actually agreed. It is not an official valuation, and it is not a promise that you can trade at that price a minute later.
Supply and demand, in plain words
Supply is how much of something people are willing to sell at a given price. Demand is how much people are willing to buy at a given price.
- If more people want to buy than sell at the current price, buyers have to offer more to get what they want. The price rises.
- If more people want to sell than buy, sellers have to accept less. The price falls.
- When the two sides roughly balance, the price drifts sideways.
A worked example (illustrative numbers). Suppose a small company's shares last traded at 20. Overnight the company announces a big new contract. In the morning, many investors want to buy at 20, but almost nobody who already owns the shares wants to sell that cheaply. Buyers start offering 21, then 22, then 23. Somewhere around 24 enough owners decide "that is a good price, I'll sell" and trading settles. The price "jumped" from 20 to 24 not because anyone recalculated the company's value with a formula, but because the balance between eager buyers and willing sellers changed.
Why expectations matter more than the present
The most important idea in this whole section is this: prices move on expectations about the future, not on the present.
A share is a claim on a company's future profits. A bond is a claim on future interest payments. A currency's value depends partly on what people expect its central bank to do next. So when new information arrives, the question investors ask is not "is this good news?" but "is this better or worse than what we already expected?"
That is why you will often see headlines that seem backwards:
- A company reports record profits and its share price falls. Usually this means investors had expected even higher profits, or the company lowered its forecast for next year.
- A company reports a loss and its share price rises. Often the loss was smaller than feared, or there is a sign that things are turning around.
Professionals call this "priced in". If everyone already expects something, it is largely reflected in today's price, and the news itself barely moves the market. Only the surprise moves it.
Other forces that move prices
Supply, demand and expectations are the engine. Several things push on that engine:
- Company or asset news: earnings, new products, lawsuits, management changes, a hack at a crypto platform, a mine closure for a commodity.
- The economy: growth, jobs and inflation change what businesses can earn and what investors need to be paid.
- Interest rates: when safe savings accounts and government bonds pay more, riskier assets have to offer more to attract money. The US Federal Reserve notes that changes in its policy rate affect stock prices by changing how attractive shares are relative to other investments (see: Interest rates, inflation, central banks and currencies).
- Risk appetite: in calm times investors are willing to own riskier things; in stressed times they rush to perceived safety. FINRA (the US Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, which oversees US brokers) calls this shift "risk-off".
- Flows: sometimes prices move because large amounts of money have to move, for example when an index adds a company and index funds must buy it, regardless of anyone's opinion.
- Liquidity: when there are few buyers and sellers, even a modest order can move the price a lot (see: Liquidity, spread, volume and who is on the other side).
Why prices move "for no reason"
Beginners often look for a single cause behind every move. Most days there is no single cause. Millions of participants with different goals, time horizons and information are constantly updating their views. A pension fund rebalancing, a trader closing a position before the weekend, and a family selling shares to pay for a house can together push a price a little without any news at all.
This randomness is normal. FINRA describes volatility as how much a price fluctuates over a short period. Some assets, such as large government bonds, usually move a little; others, such as small company shares or most crypto assets, routinely move a lot. Neither is "broken". They are just different.
Price is not the same as value
One more distinction you will meet again and again:
- Price is what someone paid in the last trade.
- Value is an estimate of what something is worth based on what it will produce in future: profits, interest, rent, usefulness.
Prices can stay far above or below most people's estimate of value for a long time. Markets aggregate a huge amount of information, but they are made of people, and people get excited and scared (see: Behavioural traps that cost investors money).
Where to see real prices
If you want to watch supply and demand at work, follow a few prices over a week. CryptoAlly (cryptoally.io) shows real prices of 2,344 assets across 42 markets, including shares, indices, commodities and crypto, which makes it easy to compare how differently they move on the same day.
Key takeaways
- A market is any place where buyers and sellers agree on a price; a quoted price is the last agreed trade, not an official value.
- More eager buyers than sellers pushes prices up; the reverse pushes them down.
- Prices move on surprises relative to expectations, not on whether news is "good" or "bad".
- Interest rates, the economy, risk appetite, money flows and liquidity all push on supply and demand.
- Small daily moves often have no single cause; that is normal.
What to remember
The common mistake is reading a headline and assuming you know which way the price "should" move. Ask instead: what did people already expect, and is this better or worse than that?
This article is educational and not personal financial advice. All investing involves risk, including loss of the money you invest.
Test yourself
- A company reports higher profits than last year, but its shares fall 5% that day. What is the most likely explanation? Answer: Investors expected even better results, or the company's outlook for the future disappointed. Prices react to surprises versus expectations.
- If many more people want to sell an asset than buy it at today's price, what tends to happen? Answer: Sellers must accept lower prices to find buyers, so the price falls until enough buyers appear.
- What is the difference between price and value? Answer: Price is what was actually paid in the most recent trade; value is an estimate of worth based on future income or usefulness. They can differ for long periods.
Sources
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.