ETFs, index funds and mutual funds

How pooled funds work, the difference between ETFs and mutual funds and between index and active management, what expense ratios and tracking error really cost you, and what the long-term evidence says.

Pooling money

A fund pools money from many investors and invests it in a portfolio of shares, bonds or other assets. Each investor owns a slice of the whole portfolio. For a small investor, this is the easiest way to diversify: one purchase can give you a share of hundreds or thousands of companies (see: Risk, return, diversification and time horizon, in Markets explanation).

The value of everything a fund holds, minus its liabilities, divided by its number of shares, is its net asset value (NAV) per share.

Mutual funds

A traditional mutual fund issues and redeems shares directly with investors. You buy or sell once a day at that day's NAV, calculated after the market closes. Many mutual funds have minimum investments, and some charge sales loads (commissions) on purchase or sale, or ongoing distribution fees, in addition to the management fee.

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs)

An ETF is a fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange like a company's shares, at prices that change throughout the day. FINRA explains the key mechanism: large financial firms called authorised participants create new ETF shares or redeem existing ones directly with the fund in large blocks, while ordinary investors buy and sell with each other on the exchange. If the ETF's market price drifts away from the value of its holdings, authorised participants can profit by creating or redeeming, which tends to pull the price back into line.

FINRA's notes on ETF costs and risks:

Index funds versus active funds

Active management sounds better: why settle for average? The evidence is sobering. S&P Dow Jones Indices' SPIVA scorecard compares active funds with their benchmarks. In its mid-year 2025 US report, the share of active US large-cap funds that underperformed the S&P 500 was about 86% over 10 years, 88% over 15 years and 91% over 20 years. In shorter periods results vary more; in the first half of 2025, 54% underperformed.

Why so many fall short:

None of this says active management can never work, only that the odds over long periods have been poor, and that cost is a big part of the reason.

Expense ratios: small numbers, big effects

The expense ratio (or ongoing charge) is the annual fee a fund deducts from its assets. It is invisible on your statement because it is taken from the fund's value, but you pay it every year.

Worked example (illustrative numbers). You invest 10,000 for 30 years, and the investments earn 6% a year before fees.

Annual feeApproximate value after 30 years
0.10%about 56,000
0.50%about 50,000
1.00%about 43,000
2.00%about 32,000

A difference of 1.9 percentage points a year means ending with roughly 40% less. Fees compound just as returns do.

Morningstar's research reaches a similar practical conclusion. A 2016 study by Russel Kinnel found expense ratios to be among the most reliable predictors of fund success: for example, the cheapest fifth of US equity funds had a 62% success rate over five years, compared with 20% for the most expensive fifth. (Morningstar counted "success" as surviving and beating the category average; it is a commercial research firm.)

Tracking error and tracking difference

Index funds do not match their index perfectly. FINRA describes tracking error as returns deviating from the benchmark, which can help or hurt. Causes include fees, trading costs, cash held by the fund, sampling (holding only some index members), and taxes on dividends. Over time, a well-run, low-cost index fund should trail its index by roughly its fees, and not much more. Comparing a fund's return with its index over several years is a simple quality check.

Choosing between fund types: a quick guide

QuestionWhy it matters
What index or strategy does it follow?Decides what you actually own
What is the expense ratio?A certain, compounding cost
How closely has it tracked its index?Shows how well it is run
How wide is the bid-ask spread (for ETFs)?A cost each time you trade
Is it leveraged or inverse?Usually unsuitable for long holding
Does it overlap with funds you already own?FINRA notes that several funds holding the same kind of shares add little diversification
Distributing or accumulating?Whether dividends are paid out or reinvested, which can matter for taxes

Key takeaways

Common mistakes

Choosing a fund on last year's performance, ignoring the expense ratio, holding several funds that own the same things, and buying leveraged ETFs as long-term investments.

This article is educational and not personal financial advice.

Test yourself

  1. What keeps an ETF's market price close to the value of its holdings? Answer: Authorised participants can create or redeem ETF shares in large blocks, profiting from any gap and so narrowing it.
  2. According to SPIVA's mid-2025 US report, roughly what share of active large-cap funds underperformed the S&P 500 over 20 years? Answer: About 91%.
  3. Why does a 1% annual fee matter so much over 30 years? Answer: It is deducted every year and compounds, reducing the base on which future returns grow.

Sources

For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.