Valuation basics, P/E and friends
How investors judge whether a share is cheap or expensive using earnings per share, the price-to-earnings ratio, price-to-sales, debt-to-equity and enterprise value, plus what "growth" and "value" investing mean.
Price is what you pay
A share price of 300 is not "expensive" and a price of 3 is not "cheap" (see: Dividends and market capitalisation). To judge whether a price is high or low, investors compare it with what the company earns, sells or owns. Those comparisons are valuation ratios. None of them tells you what a share will do next, but they help you understand what the market is assuming.
Earnings per share (EPS)
FINRA defines earnings per share as a company's total earnings divided by its shares outstanding. It lets you compare profits across companies of different sizes.
Worked example (illustrative numbers). A company earns a net profit of 500 million and has 250 million shares. EPS = 500 / 250 = 2.00 per share.
Price-to-earnings ratio (P/E)
The P/E ratio is the share price divided by EPS. FINRA describes it as showing how much investors pay for each dollar of a company's earnings.
Continuing the example: if the share trades at 40, the P/E is 40 / 2.00 = 20. Investors are paying 20 for each 1 of annual profit.
Another way to read it: the earnings yield is the inverse, EPS / price, here 2 / 40 = 5%. If profits never grew, you would be "earning" 5% a year on the price you paid. A higher P/E means a lower earnings yield, which only makes sense if investors expect profits to grow, or if alternatives such as bonds pay little.
Why P/E differs so much between companies
- Growth expectations. A company expected to double its profits will trade at a higher P/E than one expected to stand still.
- Risk. More uncertain profits usually get a lower P/E.
- Industry. FINRA stresses that ratios vary widely by industry and should be compared with the company's industry and the broader market, not in isolation.
- Interest rates. The Federal Reserve notes that rate changes affect stock prices by changing how attractive shares are relative to other investments. When safe yields are high, investors generally demand a higher earnings yield, meaning lower P/Es.
P/E pitfalls
- Trailing versus forward. A "trailing" P/E uses the past year's earnings; a "forward" P/E uses analysts' forecasts, which may be wrong.
- Depressed or inflated earnings. In a bad year a solid company's P/E can look sky-high; at the peak of a cycle a P/E can look deceptively low just before profits fall. Cyclical companies, like commodity producers, often look cheapest at the top (see: Producer stocks vs the commodity, and the real costs and risks, in Commodities 101).
- No earnings, no P/E. Loss-making companies have no meaningful P/E.
- Accounting choices can move reported earnings; that is why cash flow matters too (see: Reading an earnings report).
Price-to-sales (P/S)
FINRA lists price-to-sales, market capitalisation divided by revenue, as a way to value companies that are not yet profitable, since it ignores profit. The trade-off: a company can have huge sales and still never make money. A low P/S only means something if those sales can eventually turn into profit.
Debt-to-equity (D/E)
FINRA's version is total liabilities divided by shareholder equity. It shows how much a company relies on borrowed money. Debt magnifies results: it helps in good times and can sink a company in bad times. Again, compare within an industry: banks and utilities normally carry far more debt than software companies.
Enterprise value (EV)
Market cap only values the shares. Enterprise value is roughly market cap plus debt minus cash: what it would cost to buy the whole business, debts included. FINRA mentions that EV is used in ratios such as EV/EBITDA (EBITDA being earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation) to compare companies with different amounts of debt more fairly than P/E does.
Worked example (illustrative numbers):
| Company A | Company B | |
|---|---|---|
| Market cap | 10 billion | 10 billion |
| Debt | 0 | 6 billion |
| Cash | 1 billion | 0 |
| Enterprise value | 9 billion | 16 billion |
Same market cap, but buying B outright means taking on 6 billion of debt. B is much more expensive as a business.
Dividend yield and other ratios
You will also meet price-to-book (price compared with the accounting value of equity), dividend yield (see: Dividends and market capitalisation), return on equity (profit relative to shareholders' equity) and free cash flow yield. Each looks at the business from a different angle. No single ratio is enough.
Growth versus value
These two labels describe broad investing styles:
- Growth investing focuses on companies expected to grow revenue and earnings quickly, accepting high valuation ratios in exchange. The risk: if growth disappoints, both earnings and the multiple investors are willing to pay can fall together.
- Value investing looks for shares that seem to trade below their intrinsic worth, often with low P/E or price-to-book ratios. The risk: some shares are cheap for good reasons, the so-called value trap.
Index providers publish growth and value versions of major indices, and leadership between the two styles has shifted over different periods. Neither has won permanently, and many investors simply hold the whole market.
A simple valuation sanity check (illustrative)
A company has a P/E of 50. To judge if that is reasonable, ask: how fast must profits grow for the price to make sense? If profits grew 25% a year for five years, EPS would roughly triple, and the P/E on today's price would fall to about 16. If profits grew only 5% a year, the P/E would still be around 39 in five years. High valuations are a bet on high growth actually happening.
Key takeaways
- EPS = earnings / shares; P/E = price / EPS; earnings yield = EPS / price.
- P/E depends on growth, risk, industry and interest rates; compare within an industry.
- Price-to-sales helps with unprofitable companies; debt-to-equity and enterprise value capture borrowing.
- Ratios describe what the market assumes; they do not predict short-term moves.
- Growth and value are styles with different risks; neither always wins.
Common mistakes
Calling a share cheap because of a low P/E at a cyclical peak, ignoring debt, comparing P/Es across unrelated industries, and assuming a high-growth company is a good investment at any price.
This article is educational and not personal financial advice.
Test yourself
- A share costs 60 and EPS is 3. What are the P/E and earnings yield? Answer: P/E is 20; earnings yield is 3 / 60 = 5%.
- Why can a cyclical company look cheapest on P/E right before its shares fall? Answer: At a cycle peak, earnings are temporarily high, which makes the P/E low just before profits drop.
- Two companies have the same market cap, but one has large debts. Which has the higher enterprise value? Answer: The indebted one, because enterprise value adds debt (and subtracts cash).
Sources
For educational purposes only. This is not financial advice. Investing carries risk, including losing the money you put in. Do your own research.